Q. Our land has been in the family for several generations. In recent
years, it has appreciated greatly in value. I worry that my children won't be
able to pay the taxes on my estate and may have to sell the land we love so
dearly.
A.. You have reason to be concerned. Federal estate taxes can be as high
as 55 percent. Many heirs do not have the cash to pay these taxes and are
forced to sell the family land. Donation of an easement or a portion of
your lot to a nonprofit organization or government agency can help reduce
estate and other taxes while preserving the land. To explore your options,
make an appointment with an estate planner or attorney. Then contact the
Great Swamp Watershed Association. We’ll put you in touch with an
appropriate land-conservation group to work out an arrangement that will
enable your children to keep the land and guarantee the protection of its
natural resources.
Q. What is a conservation easement? If we donated one to an appropriate
organization, what type of restrictions would be placed on our property?
A.
When you own a property you possess a bundle of rights. An easement
is a legal conveyance that grants another party one or more rights for the
use of your land, such as the right to build a house, cut a tree or access
a stream. An increasingly popular method of preserving land is to transfer
a property's development rights to a land trust or government agency who
then retires them. The transferred deed is known as a conservation
easement. To further protect the land, additional restrictions are often
put in place. Common prohibitions in stream corridor areas include:
- No disturbance or alteration of native vegetation,
- No removal of topsoil, dredging, or excavation of stream channel,
- No dumping of trash,
- No ornamental landscaping, and
- No construction (Comastro 1997).
Aside from safeguarding ecologically valuable lands, conservation
easements may afford grantors significant tax benefits.
Q. The potential for tax breaks sounds very appealing. Tell me more.
A.
Land or conservation-easement donation to a nonprofit with 501(c)(3)
status, or to a public agency, may entitle you to a charitable gift
deduction on your income tax. Similarly, if you sell your property to an
eligible organization at a bargain rate, the difference between the sale
price and market value may count as a charitable contribution. To be taken
as a tax deduction, your gift must satisfy three requirements of Section
170 of the Internal Revenue Code:
- It must be a qualified real property interest;
- It must be given in perpetuity to a nonprofit or government; and
- It must be donated exclusively for conservation purposes.
Under current law, if the value of your charitable contribution exceeds
30 percent of your adjusted gross income, the remainder can be carried
over for up to five additional years. Keep in mind that it's up to you,
the landowner, to make the case for your deduction to the IRS. To do so,
you will need to obtain an appraisal to support the value of your
deduction, and you must file the appropriate form with your tax return.
If your land has appreciated greatly in value since you first purchased
it, you would owe capital gains taxes. You can eliminate or reduce the
amount you'd have to pay the government by donating the property or
selling it at less than its market value. Also, if you eventually sell
land encumbered by a conservation easement, your capital gains taxes would
be lower than if you hadn't retired the property's development rights.
Although it depends on your local tax assessor, there is a good chance
you will reduce your property taxes if you decrease the amount of acreage
you own or retire the development rights on your land.
It's always best to make succession arrangements while you are still
alive. This will help ensure that your wishes are carried out and reduce
the estate tax burden for your heirs. That said, a new post-mortem clause
in the tax code will give your heirs nine months after your death to agree
to retire the development rights on a portion of the land in your estate,
potentially preventing a forced sell-off. Also, if certain criteria are
met, Section 2031 of the tax code allows up to 40 percent of the value of
land subject to a conservation easement to be exempt from estate taxes.
Q. We've been planning to subdivide our lot, as my husband and I need money
for our retirement. Are there any alternatives?
A.
You may not need to develop your property to generate income.
Consider a bargain sale of your ecologically valuable land to a nonprofit
or government agency, whereby you sell at less than the market rate. There
are many other income-generating, land conservation options. One
possibility is a limited development whereby you divide off and sell one
lot on the least environmentally sensitive portion of your property. You
could then place a conservation easement on the section of your property
containing woodlands, wetlands or other distinctive natural features. Or,
you could transfer the title to these ecologically valuable habitats to a
conservation group. Portions of Peter Frelinghuysen's property and Hartley
Farms, both in Harding Township, were protected by combining limited
development with easement and full-title conveyance.
Q.
How does this project fit in with other local conservation efforts?
A. The Streamways Project is designed to complement other conservation
efforts in the area. For example, the Harding Land Trust is developing a
pamphlet on Open Spaces and Natural Places of Harding Township. In
addition, the Trust holds several easements on Primrose Brook. The Harding
Environmental Commission, meanwhile, is cooperating with the Watershed
Association on a build-out analysis of the township, which will dramatize
the importance of open-space retention. The Trust for Public Land is
working to expand Morristown National Historical Park and the Great Swamp
National Wildlife Refuge. New Jersey Conservation Foundation holds title
to a number of easements and fully owned properties along the Upper
Passaic and Primrose Brook.
The Ten Towns Committee is working to enact municipal ordinances to
protect the tributaries of the Great Swamp. The group also has a grant
from the NJDEP to implement improvements -- such as the creation of
vegetative buffers -- along stream corridors. Several partners, including
the USDA-Natural Resources Conservation Service, USDA-Forest Service,
Morris County Soil Conservation District, the Passaic River Coalition and
a private landowner, have planted a forested buffer along an 1100-foot
section of Primrose Brook. The project is intended to demonstrate the
short- and long-term benefits of such buffers to water quality and fish
and wildlife habitat. In addition, many of the watershed's municipalities
and its two counties, as well as the State of New Jersey, are actively
pursuing open space preservation (see next question for more details).
Q.
There seem to be a number of new funding sources for open space
preservation in our region. Can this money be used to conserve my land?
A.
It's a definite possibility. In recent years, Morris County,
Somerset County, Bernards Township, Bernardsville, Chatham Township,
Harding Township, Long Hill, Mendham Borough and Township, and Morris
Township have all established open-space trust funds. To raise money for
these funds, landowners are taxed up to a few cents for every $100 of
assessed property value. Monies are used to buy parkland, conserve natural
areas and retain agricultural lands. Since its creation in 1992, Morris
County's Open Space and Farmland Preservation Trust Fund has helped save
thousands of acres in the county.
In November of 1998, New Jersey residents approved a ballot measure to
establish a stable source of funding for open-space and farmland
preservation. The Garden State Preservation Trust was subsequently
established and allocated $1 billion of sales tax revenue over the next 10
years. In addition, voters authorized the issuance of up to $1 billion in
revenue bonds to fund the trust. With these monies and the efforts of
local and nonprofit groups, Governor Whitman has set the ambitious goal of
protecting one million acres of open space in New Jersey during the next
decade.
The new stable source of funding will help support the state's Green
Acres program, which issues grants and low-interest loans to
municipalities, counties, and nonprofits seeking to purchase recreation
and conservation lands. Typically, a landowner works with a local
government or nonprofit, which then applies for these funds. Sometimes the
state negotiates directly with a property owner.
Keep in mind that with Green Acres and open-space trust funds there is
strong competition and a limited supply of capital. In addition, the
application and negotiation processes can be quite lengthy. To overcome
these obstacles, land trusts and government bodies sometimes form
partnerships to pool their resources and combine funding, allowing them to
save more land than had they pursued an acquisition alone.
Q. My wife and I are considering donating an easement but we have two young
children and are uncomfortable allowing strangers on our property. Must we grant
public access? How frequently will the easement be monitored and what does this
entail?
A.. Although some easements grant public access, many do not. Unlike
Patriots Path, a recreational greenway that runs through Morris County,
the Streamways Project is not focused on trail creation. If you do convey
an easement, you can expect a representative from the group holding the
deed to conduct a baseline survey. The easement monitor will walk the
property grounds, take photographs and notes, and ascertain boundaries.
The baseline survey is required by the IRS if you wish to take a tax
deduction. Also, it will serve as a point of comparison in future years.
Following the initial survey, the monitor will make annual visits, to
ensure that the terms of easement are being met and to offer stewardship
suggestions. The monitor will contact you in advance of his or her visit
to set a convenient time and may even invite you to come along.
Afterwards, you will be sent a report. If necessary, the easement holder
will work with you to address any problems or concerns.
Q. We plan to move in few years. What will happen to the conservation
easement on our property?
A.. The easement will remain in place; however, it is a good idea to
include a reverter clause in the deed. Such a provision names a back-up
easement holder should the primary enforcer cease to exist or carry out
its duties.
In addition, although your easement should be referenced in your deed,
you should make sure that your real-estate agent tells potential buyers
about it so they are not surprised. If the buyers have questions that you
or your agent cannot answer, they might find it helpful to meet or speak
with the easement holder before the closing.
The presence of a conservation easement and proximity to other
protected lands can actually be used as a marketing tool. Many prospective
buyers are attracted to real estate with scenic, wildlife and recreational
values, and some may be willing to pay a premium if surrounding lands
won't be fully developed.
Q. A portion of our property is farmland-assessed. How will a conservation
easement or title transfer affect this status?
A.
The Farmland Assessment Act of 1964 enables New Jersey residents to
save up to 90 percent in property taxes on lands used for agricultural and
horticultural purposes, including forestry. If you transfer title to
another party, the farmland assessment status remains in effect as long as
the new owner chooses to participate in the program. If, however, there is
a change in land use, the new owner may trigger rollback taxes (taxes that
would have been paid had the land been assessed at the standard rate minus
taxes paid under farmland assessment).
It is possible to have both a farmland assessment and an easement on
your land. However, the easement has to be crafted to enable you to meet
the minimum income requirements of the lowered tax status. For example, an
easement on agricultural land or hayfields should allow you to harvest
crops. An easement on woodland can be written to allow for selective
timber harvesting, thinning of trees for firewood, or maple syrup
production using forestry methods that minimize soil disturbance and other
negative environmental impacts.
If greater than half a property is wooded, the owner must work with a
state-approved forester and implement a ten-year forest management plan to
be eligible for farmland assessment (Frontier Forestry web site, see
references).
Q. We want to do our part to protect the Great Swamp Watershed but we aren't
ready to donate an easement. What else can we do to help?
A.
The most important thing you can do is to employ Best Management
Practices (BMPs) on your land. These are strategies considered to be most
effective in protecting water, air and land and controlling the release of
pollutants. For example, you should maintain existing tree cover,
underlying shrubs and native vegetation, particularly along waterways; use
landscapers familiar with integrated pest management (IPM) or other
strategies that reduce reliance on chemicals; control your pets and
livestock by keeping them away from waterways; use nonchemical deicers
such as sand or ash on your driveway; and discard hazardous waste at
approved disposal sites.
For a more formal arrangement, you could work with a conservation
organization or watershed group to develop a management plan for your
property and then agree to follow stewardship practices that will maintain
or enhance its ecological and scenic value. This might be as simple as
leaving your land alone, or it might involve revegetating stream banks or
limiting the mowing of your meadows to better accommodate grassland birds.
The management techniques selected will depend on your land's topography
and habitat types.